DISH Network by DishPronto       DIRECTV by RapidSatellite.com    banner35   

PDA

View Full Version : HD recording


jamesnmandy
04-20-2005, 12:50 AM
I am able to record HD broadcasts with my COmcast provided Motorola DCT 6412 STB, however I noticed two things different from regular DVR recordings, wanted to see if anyone else has noticed this.

An HD recording cannot be paused, rewinded, fast forwarded, etc......any non-HD recordings can be manipulated as would be expected.

and

I recorded the 1984 documentary "Speed", and during playback, there were a few scenes where two jet-engined cars were lighting up the afterburners at night. When there was alot of bright action like you can imagine, the picture seemed to lose it's integrity, like becoming "blocky" or "pixelated", very noticeably.
My only theory on this, based on my fairly good understanding and experience of computers is that the bandwidth of the HD signal at these points reached a point which was too high for the recording system to be able to record in entirety, and it is losing some of the data in the conversion to the hard drive, perhaps a limitation of the cpu or memory subsystem in the DVR, or maybe a limitation of the actual hard drive itself?

57U
04-20-2005, 12:55 AM
Let me discuss the macroblocking issue you saw on "Speed". See the HDTV FAQ on "acronyms and definitions" and look at "macroblocking".

Macroblocking has nothing to do with the STB, but you are correct that it's due to "bandwidth". HD signals are initially over 1 Gb/sec and are compressed by a factor of over 50 to a maximum of 19.4 Mb/sec by MPEG before broadcast. This causes macroblocking on images like you saw, or fast moving images, or nature scenes, etc.

You would see the same on a non-DVR STB, but you probably couldn't analyze it like you can on a DVR (once it's working properly ;) ). You'll notice the same macroblocking on SD digital channels too, as these are compressed by the cable company.

I don't know why you can't FF your HD recording. Something is amiss.

kdog044
04-20-2005, 01:55 PM
I am able to record HD broadcasts with my COmcast provided Motorola DCT 6412 STB, however I noticed two things different from regular DVR recordings, wanted to see if anyone else has noticed this.

An HD recording cannot be paused, rewinded, fast forwarded, etc......any non-HD recordings can be manipulated as would be expected.You need to have Comcast check your box. I FF and REW HD programs all the time with mine.

           


DISH Network by DishPronto       DIRECTV by RapidSatellite.com    banner35       Low Mortgage Rates