View Full Version : Samsung HLN617 vs Sony KF-60DX100
sundial2k
05-27-2003, 10:25 AM
I need some advice. I cannot find a retailer that has both of these sets on display, so I can't directly compare them. I have read both good and bad reviews of each of them, and now I don't know which way to go.
I know that I want a TV that burn-in is not an issue, which is the reason I am looking at DLP and LCD.
Those of you that own either of these sets, please let me know the reasons that let you to your decision.
robsuts
07-01-2003, 09:17 AM
I thought the kf-60dx100 sony lcd was replaced by the kf-60xbr800. In the fall, there will be a kf-60we610 which will retail around $4k. I've seen the dlp next to the lcd and found the lcd to be brighter, but the blacks were noticeably less black on the lcd screen.
proacman
07-02-2003, 08:38 AM
From what I have seen, the DLP sets do have slightly better blacks, but no where as good as a CRT-based TV. The main advantage of the SONY LCT RPTV (yes, the current model is the 60XBR800) is brightness. I have no problem watching it during the day in a well lit room.
At 4K for the new 60inch model (coming in July?), I don't think you can beat it at that price. Of course, you can wait until the LCOS sets come down in price, since they seem to offer better blacks and good brightness (and no burn-in), but right now they are too expensive in my opinion ($9k for a 50inch).
Phillips and Toshiba have both announced cheaper LCoS sets (720P instead of 1080P like the $9k Toshiba) Although not cheap, they will likely be in the same "price range".
I'm not advocating LCoS over DLP or LCD, simply that they all appear to be technologies that have certain advantages (720P) and disadvantages ($, other issues as mentioned in the FAQ on types of HDTV)
ShackShock
07-05-2003, 11:45 AM
I've been told my new Samsung 61" will be delivered in the next hour or so. I'm replacing a 36 inch Sony Wega with this model, and I've got a Samsung HD DirecTV receiver. The anticipation is killing me. I can't sit still. Ready to call DirecTV and order the HD package and start enjoying the views.
I've read some of the posts about some issues with the DLP, so I think I've got my ducks in a row and ready to rock and roll with it.
I'll let you guys know how it works.
ShackShock
07-05-2003, 02:27 PM
After a few wary moments with the DirecTV rep, I got the HD package working. My oh my, what a picture! HDNet and Discovery Net are looking fabulous. SD channels look pretty good, and my DVD player also looks great. Awaiting Sunday night baseball on ESPN to see a good ESPN picture.
I would strongly recommend this TV, even after only about 90 minutes of viewing!
HexDump
07-06-2003, 03:29 PM
in the 50 inch model. They were at a store in Houston called the Great Indoors.
Both had pretty good pictures. The Samsung was slightly grainier.
The signal was a SD feed. I am still at a loss as to which I will buy.
I am waiting for the Sony KF-60WE610 which is supposed to be out later this year.
HAppy hunting
ShackShock
07-06-2003, 03:38 PM
I saw the 60 inch Sony Grand Wega next to the 61 inch Samsung DLP side by side when I bought my Samsung. The difference was minimal. I will agree that the Sony was a bit brighter, but the Samsung had better blacks and better movement. Some SD channels at home are grainier than others. For instance, the NASCAR race last night wasn't that great, but Nat'l Geographic and FoxSports today were pretty good. For SD channels, I can still watch my 36" Sony Wega tube.
But I'm currently watching HDNet, and the picture is fabulous. I find myself laughing to myself when it hits me how good this picture is.
