neuronbob

I was watching HDNet this morning and they showed the CEA "Super Panel" meeting from 3/10/03, in which Jack Valenti (CEO of MPAA), Robert Sachs (NCTA), Gary Shapiro (CEA), and Jon Healey (LA Times). What I saw was very disturbing.

Valenti specifically discussed HDCP and is insisting on "closing the analog loophole" by using a broadcast flag. In other words, screwing the buyers of 5 million HD-compatible sets of the ability to watch anything other than pre-recorded material and broadcast TV, and basic cable/satellite.

When asked why the consumer electronics industry was continuing to sell analog HD-compatible sets, Shapiro said that his industry was selling the sets that people want. I just want a set that will be able to show HD programs in 5 years. Shapiro says later in the discussion that "analog set will be working for a very long time with a VCR, DVD, and video game, with prerecorded products." Yeah, but what about PPV?

Jack Valenti seems to say that the electronics manufacturers have known that HDCP was coming and was likely going to be approved for some time and should not have led consumers to buy analog sets. The industry, OTOH, seems content to screw buyers without warning us that the TVs we buy are going to be obsolete shortly.

I'm sure all this has been discussed before, but hearing this is very frustrating. I just spent $900 on a TV that will, if the MPAA gets its way, will be obsolete shortly. Further, the CEA (electronics manufacturers) don't give a s*** that there are a lot of us who spent money without knowing until after their purchase that this debate was going on. Perhaps there is a way to upgrade my analog Samsung set to accept a DVI card? I hope I'm not overreacting, but I was totally unaware of this debate until after I bought the TV.

Here's the pertinent link to find the transcript. Click on "Transcript of the Industry Insider Panel" to download the .pdf of the panel discussion for your own perusal.

Thanks for letting me vent.

__________________
Samsung TXM3096WHF
Panasonic S35 Progressive Scan DVD Player
Samsung SIR-TS160 DirecTV/OTA HDTV tuner
RCA ANT200 Powered Indoor Antenna

57U

1. Anyone buying an HDTV should have been aware of this situation, as it has been known for about 18 months or more.

2. A lot of people paid a lot more than you for their HDTV.

3. This situation is not cast in stone and the outcome is not yet known. There has been a lot of conjecture on this issue, however, that's all it is - conjecture.

4. Sit back and enjoy your set. It will surely serve you well for many years to come.

5. Those 5 million other buyers will not let this situation get out of hand. As a minimum, this large a market will be a good market for someone with a "workaround" (even an illegal one).

6. The MPAA is much more concerned with recording of HD signals than they are with viewing them and that's where most of the discussion has been.

__________________
57U - Toronto, Rogers Cable, SA8300HD, 500GB HDD & Hitachi 61UWX10B HDTV, Yamaha RX-V1 A/V Receiver, Martin Logan Speakers. Photos --> 57U's HT

SA8300HD, 250GB HDD & KDL40W3000 (Upstairs)

Please don't PM me with questions that can (and should) be asked in the forum, thanks. Personal Question? Fire away.

neuronbob

I was really unaware of the debate until after I bought the set and started looking around at home theatre sites (especially this one, which has been a great resource!! ). The great mass of the public is totally unaware of the issue. Salespeople just want to move TV sets and won't address the issue unless it is discussed. Believe me, my buddies who are looking to upgrade will know now, from me!

And I really feel sorry for folks who spent 1000s on their plasma....

__________________
Samsung TXM3096WHF
Panasonic S35 Progressive Scan DVD Player
Samsung SIR-TS160 DirecTV/OTA HDTV tuner
RCA ANT200 Powered Indoor Antenna

isando

I just recently purchased a Hitachi 46F500. I would not have purchased it had it not had DVI/HDCP. Thanks to great message boards such as this one and a few others, I had the information necessary to make an informed decision. Joe Six-Lenses will not likely have a clue about DVI. Even today if you go into Sears, Tweeter, Best Buy or Circuit City, many of the hdtvs still do not have DVI. I dont see how the MPAA thinks it can get away with this. Hopefully it cant. But just in case, I got DVI. Wont it be delicious irony if DVI loses out to Firewire?

__________________
Sony KP-46WT500 RPTV
Magnavox 5534C RPTV
Philips DVDQ35AT DVD
My DVD Collection

akthor

DVI? Is this the DVI connector on the back of the set that you hook a HDTV receiver to?

__________________
Hitachi 51UWX20B
Samsung P231 DVD
Magnavox HI-FI VCR
Denon AVR-2802
6 Luxman M-120A Amps
Front Speakers: Altec Lansing Model 15's
Front Center: HTD Level 3's
Rear Speakers: Cerwin Vega 1215MKII's (15" floor loaded woofers used as LFE Subs)
Rear Center: HTD Level 3's

57U

Yes. (akthor, were you trying to be funny?)

__________________
57U - Toronto, Rogers Cable, SA8300HD, 500GB HDD & Hitachi 61UWX10B HDTV, Yamaha RX-V1 A/V Receiver, Martin Logan Speakers. Photos --> 57U's HT

SA8300HD, 250GB HDD & KDL40W3000 (Upstairs)

Please don't PM me with questions that can (and should) be asked in the forum, thanks. Personal Question? Fire away.

akthor

No not at all. So if I have a DVI connector on the back of my TV I should be all set for the future?

__________________
Hitachi 51UWX20B
Samsung P231 DVD
Magnavox HI-FI VCR
Denon AVR-2802
6 Luxman M-120A Amps
Front Speakers: Altec Lansing Model 15's
Front Center: HTD Level 3's
Rear Speakers: Cerwin Vega 1215MKII's (15" floor loaded woofers used as LFE Subs)
Rear Center: HTD Level 3's

57U

There are no guarantees, but you'll be more "set for the future" than those of us with component video inputs only...

There has been some discussion about DVI with HDCP & Firewire, but, let's see how this shakes out before worrying about it, now that we have our TVs.

__________________
57U - Toronto, Rogers Cable, SA8300HD, 500GB HDD & Hitachi 61UWX10B HDTV, Yamaha RX-V1 A/V Receiver, Martin Logan Speakers. Photos --> 57U's HT

SA8300HD, 250GB HDD & KDL40W3000 (Upstairs)

Please don't PM me with questions that can (and should) be asked in the forum, thanks. Personal Question? Fire away.

neuronbob

I am hoping the MPAA doesn't get away with this. However, as you read the transcript from the meeting, Valenti feels that the lack of "protection" will limit the amount of TV available in HD.

Sounds like the same issues people had with VCRs, and that certainly didn't lead to a decrease in sales...

And akthor, you should be set for the immediate future with your DVI port, as long as it supports HDMI (some don't if my readings are correct).

__________________
Samsung TXM3096WHF
Panasonic S35 Progressive Scan DVD Player
Samsung SIR-TS160 DirecTV/OTA HDTV tuner
RCA ANT200 Powered Indoor Antenna

akthor

Thanks guys.

__________________
Hitachi 51UWX20B
Samsung P231 DVD
Magnavox HI-FI VCR
Denon AVR-2802
6 Luxman M-120A Amps
Front Speakers: Altec Lansing Model 15's
Front Center: HTD Level 3's
Rear Speakers: Cerwin Vega 1215MKII's (15" floor loaded woofers used as LFE Subs)
Rear Center: HTD Level 3's

mhdiab

So do you guys think that this is why Toshiba is selling theirs DVI compatible, but actually not able to provide the DVI "adapter". What I am saying is they know that it isn't needed yet and haven't fully closed the design on the DVI "adapter" (correct term?) because they don't know how it will be finalized?

If this is the case then that is great and a good move by Toshiba not to produce something and then 2 years down the road be like - sorry you bought the wrong one

Or will the Toshiba as well be screwed if it goes with HDCP & Firewire????

Thanks

57U

This is the reason that Mits developed the "promise module" and Toshiba the "DVI compatible/upgradable" sets.

__________________
57U - Toronto, Rogers Cable, SA8300HD, 500GB HDD & Hitachi 61UWX10B HDTV, Yamaha RX-V1 A/V Receiver, Martin Logan Speakers. Photos --> 57U's HT

SA8300HD, 250GB HDD & KDL40W3000 (Upstairs)

Please don't PM me with questions that can (and should) be asked in the forum, thanks. Personal Question? Fire away.

neuronbob

Would've been nice if all the manufacturers would've done that. As you can tell, I ended up with a Samsung, primarily because of the picture quality and nearly perfect size for my living space. They are releasing DVI-compatible TVs this summer. It is doubtful they have allowed for upgradeability in their current TV line--you get what you pay for, I guess! (Lesson learned)

__________________
Samsung TXM3096WHF
Panasonic S35 Progressive Scan DVD Player
Samsung SIR-TS160 DirecTV/OTA HDTV tuner
RCA ANT200 Powered Indoor Antenna

57U

Exactly, but hey, a "promise module" costs more than your entire TV. Enjoy your TV - it'll be fine for years to come and you can buy a plasma with the money you saved in 5 years...

__________________
57U - Toronto, Rogers Cable, SA8300HD, 500GB HDD & Hitachi 61UWX10B HDTV, Yamaha RX-V1 A/V Receiver, Martin Logan Speakers. Photos --> 57U's HT

SA8300HD, 250GB HDD & KDL40W3000 (Upstairs)

Please don't PM me with questions that can (and should) be asked in the forum, thanks. Personal Question? Fire away.

neuronbob

I'm already enjoying the TV--it's a load of fun trying to find HD programming, actually! And you're absolutely right. I'll be able to buy a plasma with Firewire and HDCP in 5 years, I'm sure.

__________________
Samsung TXM3096WHF
Panasonic S35 Progressive Scan DVD Player
Samsung SIR-TS160 DirecTV/OTA HDTV tuner
RCA ANT200 Powered Indoor Antenna